STRING SEXTET NO. 1 in B-FLAT MAJOR, OP. 18
Recording: Verdi Quartet (Susanne Rabenschlag, 1st Violin;
Johannes Hehrmann, 2nd violin; Karin Wolf, viola; Zoltan
Paulich, cello) with Hermann Voss, 2nd Viola; Peter Buck, 2nd
cello [Hänssler 98.539]
Published 1862.
Brahms regarded the
string quartet as a hallowed genre, and treated it with the same
reverence he famously held for the symphony. In his first works
for strings without piano, he added “extra” instruments to the quartet
to get a sense of writing for strings while having two more instruments
to aid him with harmony and texture. The advantage of this is
seen at the outset of the first sextet, when the first cello presents
the opening theme against the bass provided by the second cello,
something that would be impossible in a quartet. The pair of
violas often plays in parallel harmony, creating another sound that
cannot be heard in a quartet. In a sense, Brahms was conceding
that it was easier to write for more instruments to “get his feet wet”
before attempting the leaner and more “hallowed” genre of the quartet,
for which he claimed to have made over 20 abortive attempts. The
first of the two sextets is an excellent product of the youthful Brahms
and technically, the earliest of his chamber works that is played with
any regularity (the original version of the Op. 8 Trio being rarely
heard today). He still uses a traditional Beethovenian scherzo
movement here (in third position), something he would largely abandon
later on (but, as he would do later, he sets it in a contrasting
key). The outer movements, while extremely expansive, have very
clear-cut classical forms. Both are sunny, melodious movements in
an almost “pastoral” vein. There are parallels between them, as
both begin with the cello presenting the principal theme, and both end
with prominent plucked (pizzicato)
parts. The second movement is perhaps the most famous. It
is a noble, if quite square Theme and Variations that boasts an
especially exquisite coda. The variations are structurally
strict, but diverse transformations. This movement exists in an
often-played version for solo piano. Its stern minor key adds a
striking contrast to the rest of the Sextet’s brightness. The
character of the work is often compared to that of the two orchestral
Serenades (Opp. 11 and 16) with which it is roughly contemporary.
ONLINE
SCORE FROM IMSLP (First Edition from Brahms-Institut Lübeck)
1st
Movement:
Allegro ma non troppo (Sonata-Allegro form). B-FLAT MAJOR, 3/4
time.
EXPOSITION
0:00 [m. 1]--Theme 1. A
warm, expressive melody played by the
first cello in a swaying triple meter, with the second cello
accompanying as a bass. The first viola plays an undulating
background.
0:17 [m. 10]--The violins
enter, leading into a second statement of the
melody from the first violin and first viola in octaves. It is
more fully scored, with the first cello and second violin playing the
undulating background. The second viola has not yet entered.
0:32 [m. 20]--A new phrase
increases the intensity of the theme.
The second viola finally enters, joining the first cello and second
violin on syncopated repeated notes as the music makes an unexpected
detour to D-flat major.
0:50 [m. 31]--The first violin
plays a winding broken-chord line, then,
with the first viola, leads the other instruments, who slide upward
chromatically (skipping no notes) in thirds, to a gentle cadence in
B-flat.
1:09 [m. 43]--Transition.
A fragment of Theme 1 in second violin
and second cello, against a syncopated background from second viola,
leads to a new element in the first violin. This is a series of
winding, melancholy triplets with active accompaniment from the first
viola. Motion toward F major.
1:23 [m. 51]--Restatement at a
higher level of the Theme 1 fragment
with syncopated background, followed by winding, melancholy triplets in
the first violin. The accompaniment moves from first viola to
second cello, with the bass remaining in the first cello. The
triplets are extended by two bars. The first violin slows to a
“straight” rhythm. Brahms marks for a slight slowing as the music
reaches the new key of A major.
1:41 [m. 61]--Transition
Theme. While this is a new melody, it is
in the “wrong” key and another melody in the expected key of F will
follow. This melody is therefore properly labeled as a
“transition theme.” Plucked notes from second viola and second
cello punctuate short rising, richly harmonized phrases from the other
instruments. These gentle phrases strive ever higher. The
accompanying instruments play two bowed “bridge“ passages, then the
second viola introduces distinctive plucked rising arpeggios.
These arpeggios are then bowed by first cello and second viola as the
music moves decisively to F major.
2:18 [m. 85]--Theme 2.
Right at the cadence, the first cello
begins the sweeping, exuberant second theme. Second
violin and second viola provide an accompaniment in a clashing triplet
rhythm with wide arpeggios. The second cello provides a steady
bass (F major).
2:30 [m. 94]--First violin and
first viola take Theme 2. The
first cello joins the accompaniment, but in straight rhythms like the
theme. The theme reaches higher and higher before being suddenly
interrupted.
2:42 [m. 103]--A brief moment
of disquiet as the violas and first cello
pluck an isolated figure from Theme 2 with dissonant, chromatic
notes. These are played against a long held note (then a third)
from the first violin and a dissonant, oscillating second violin.
Bowed cellos on the Theme 2 fragment lead to the Closing Theme.
2:48 [m. 107]--Closing
Theme. It is derived from the Theme 2
fragment that was just isolated. It begins in gentle harmony,
with the cellos providing an oscillating line in octaves. On the
second phrase, the violas move away from the melody and provide
dovetailing descents in response, which are picked up by the cellos,
who play them in rhythm with the theme (F major).
3:00 [m. 115]--The first violin
adds a new countermelody with dotted
(long-short) rhythm on top of the Theme 2 fragment. The second
violin and first viola begin to play plucked chords. The music
very gradually intensifies.
3:11 [m. 123]--The
countermelody is transferred to the second viola and
second cello. The violins now play the dovetailing descending
figures. The first viola continues its plucked chords, now played
with the first cello. The climax is reached, but quickly subsides
as the exposition ends with echoes of the countermelody from the second
violin and second viola. A hint at Theme 1 in the second violin
and first cello serves as a transition to the repeat.
EXPOSITION REPEATED
3:38 [m. 1]--Theme 1 from the
first cello, as at the beginning.
3:51 [m. 10]--Violin statement
of Theme 1 melody, as at 0:17.
4:07 [m. 20]--New phrase and
motion to D-flat major, as at 0:32.
4:24 [m. 31]--Winding line and
cadence in B-flat, as at 0:50.
4:43 [m. 43]--Transition with
Theme 1 fragment and melancholy triplets, as at 1:09.
4:57 [m. 51]--Continuation of
transition at higher level and motion to A major, as at 1:23.
5:15 [m. 61]--Transition Theme
in A major, as at 1:41.
5:52 [m. 85]--Theme 2 from the
cello in F major, as at 2:18.
6:04 [m. 94]--First violin and viola on
Theme 2, as at 2:30.
6:16 [m. 103]--Dissonant moment
of disquiet, as at 2:42.
6:22 [m. 107]--Closing Theme
derived from Theme 2 fragment, as at 2:48.
6:34 [m. 115]--Countermelody
from first violin and slow intensification, as at 3:00.
6:46 [m. 123]--Buildup to
climax and end of exposition, as at 3:11. The hint at Theme 1 in
the second violin and first cello now transitions out of the exposition
into the development section.
DEVELOPMENT
7:12 [m. 141]--The development
emerges seamlessly and begins to work
with Theme 1 in the key of G minor (relative to the home major key of
B-flat). Fragments of Theme 1 are passed between the first viola
and the two violins. The accompanying instruments are
plucked. An arching figure in shorter notes emerges, leading into
the next section.
7:38 [m. 158]--Motion to a new
minor key, A minor. A three-note
descending arpeggio beginning on an upbeat is isolated from Theme
1. It was heard in the previous passage as well. It is
passed between second violin and first cello in alternation. The
two violas in harmony present overlapping, syncopated responses that
connect the violin and cello. The music moves to D minor.
The first violin enters with the arpeggio beginning on the downbeat,
creating a rather dense counterpoint at the end of the passage.
8:00 [m. 173]--Forceful
development of the triplets from the transition
at 1:09 and 4:43 [m. 43] in G minor. First violin and then first
viola
play them against a rich and fully scored accompaniment in “straight”
rhythm. Buildup to a huge climax with repeated notes and full
scoring for all six instruments. The two violins play in triplet
rhythm. The violins and cellos suddenly drop out at the top of
the climax, leaving the two violas, whose pulsations slow to longer
notes, to bring the music back down to a quiet level.
8:29 [m. 192]--Development of
the transition theme from 1:41 and 5:15 [m. 61] in
E minor. It is first heard in the violins against the continuing
viola pulsation. It is then played by the first cello. The
cello statement changes key, to D minor. The two violins and the
first cello then play the theme in imitation, leading to a full cadence
in D minor.
9:02 [m. 214]--Re-transition,
beginning with the D-minor cadence.
Note the highly syncopated bass in the second cello. Material
from Theme 1 is passed between the first cello and the violas.
There is a buildup of intensity as the music moves back to the home key
of B-flat. The syncopation moves up to first cello and second
viola. The violins enter with the Theme 1 material Then the
syncopations are taken by the violins over a huge swelling of volume as
the moment of return is approached.
RECAPITULATION
9:34 [m. 234]--Theme 1.
It enters in a new, powerful, and fully
scored version. The lower instruments take the melody while the
violins (and second cello) continue the syncopations from the end of
the development.
9:48 [m. 243]--The new phrase
from 0:32 and 4:07 [m. 20] begins in the violins,
with the syncopation moving to the violas and first cello. It
moves in a different direction from before, avoiding the motion to
D-flat. It maintains the power and builds even more, leading to
very high notes in the first violin over richly scored accompaniment.
10:09 [m. 257]--The winding
broken-chord line from 0:50 and 4:24 [m. 31] begins
in the second violin. The first violin adds high octave doubling
on certain two-note figures within the broken-chord line. As in
the exposition, sliding chromatic notes in the violas and cellos are
heard as the violins lead to a cadence. This time, however, the
intensity from the beginning of the recapitulation is still maintained,
and the cadence is powerful rather than gentle.
10:27 [m. 269]--Transition.
It is very similar to 1:09 and 4:43 [m. 43] in
the exposition, but an alteration to the triplet line causes the music
to stay at home in B-flat instead of moving toward F.
10:41 [m. 277]--The passage is
analogous to 1:23 and 4:57 [m. 51], but the second
violin plays a decorated variant of the Theme 1 fragment. The
triplet passage now begins at the same level as the previous one
instead of higher. Other than the fact that the active
accompaniment stays in the first viola instead of moving to the cello,
the triplets are completely analogous, with their extension and
slowing. Because of the alteration from before, the new arrival
key is D major rather than A major.
10:59 [m. 287]--Transition
Theme
from 1:41 and 5:15 [m. 61]. The
recapitulation is supposed to remain in the home key, but in order to
get there, Brahms sets the “extra” transition theme in D major, which
has the same relationship to B-flat as A major did to F in the
exposition. It follows the theme from the exposition rather
closely, with some important voicing changes. These include the
plucked accompaniment being played only by second cello, and the later,
faster rising plucked arpeggio being played by the first viola instead
of the second. Decisive motion back to B-flat and strong arrival.
11:38 [m. 311]--Theme 2, now in
the home key. It is played by the
first viola instead of the first cello. The accompanying
instruments are the same as in the exposition at 2:18 and 5:52 [m. 85].
11:51 [m. 320]--Since the first
viola had the previous presentation,
Brahms now assigns the first cello to double the first violin on the
restatement of Theme 2. The first viola takes the first cello’s
previous “straight” accompaniment as heard at 2:30 and 6:04 [m.
94].
Buildup of intensity as the music reaches higher before being
interrupted.
12:03 [m. 329]--Moment of
disquiet, as at 2:42 and 6:16 [m. 103]. The first
viola now harmonizes with the long notes in the first violin, leaving
the dissonant plucked figure to the second viola and first cello.
12:10 [m. 333]--Closing theme
in
the home key, with the same scoring as
at 2:48 and 6:22 [m. 107].
12:22 [m. 341]--First violin
countermelody, as at 3:00 and 6:34 [m. 115].
Very gradual intensification. The plucked chords are played by
second violin and second (not first) viola, and there are other scoring
reassignments.
12:34 [m. 349]--Countermelody
transferred to first viola and second
cello, similar to 3:11 and 6:46 [m. 123]. Climax and subsequent
dissolution/relaxation to end the recapitulation. Essentially,
the viola parts are reversed from the exposition in this passage.
CODA
12:55 [m. 363]--The coda begins
with a dreamy, lingering passage based
on Theme 1. It is similar to the beginning of the development,
but remains in the major key. The first cello leads, followed by
first viola, and the other instruments join in a final swell of
intensity and retreat that includes chromatic notes. The second
violin plays an oscillating accompanying, the second cello a long pedal
bass note that becomes syncopated during the retreat. Descending
figures lead smoothly into the final passage as the music slows.
13:33 [m. 387]--Brahms marks
the slower ending “Poco più
Moderato.” The first viola plays the Closing Theme in pizzicato (plucked strings).
All instruments except the second cello, which holds over its pedal
bass note, are now plucked, punctuating the melody with chords.
The first violin takes over from the first viola, and the second cello
finally abandons its long bowed note to join the pizzicato. All remains quiet
and gentle through a high-reaching arrival and subsequent confirming
cadence gestures. Then suddenly, the instruments take up their
bows for the strong final chords.
14:03--END OF MOVEMENT [398 mm.]
2nd Movement:
Andante, ma
moderato (Theme and Variations). D MINOR, 2/4 time.
0:00 [m. 1]--Theme, Part
1. The first viola presents the broad,
noble, and somewhat tragic theme. It begins with an upbeat.
The violins are absent. The lower instruments have accompanying
chords that are steady, strong, and austere. Note the many florid
decorations in the melody. Part 1 ends on a half-close.
0:24 [m. 9]--Theme, Part 1,
Varied Repeat. The first violin now
plays the theme an octave higher, and with the entry of the violins,
the accompaniment becomes more rhythmic and full, especially in the
first viola, which just gave up the melody to the first violin.
It plays very forceful, rhythmic gestures.
0:45 [m. 17]--Theme, Part
2. The second phrase of the Theme is
again given to the first viola, with the violins dropping out.
The steady accompaniment continues. Part 2 is somewhat more
striving and tense than Part 1. The cadence is extremely
satisfying. The viola reaches into its very highest register.
1:08 [m. 25]--Theme, Part 2,
Varied Repeat. The second phrase is
repeated an octave higher by the first violin. The accompaniment
is again more full and rhythmic. The cadence is even more
satisfying as the violin reaches into its very high register.
1:29 [m. 33]--Variation 1, Part
1. The first cello begins a
broken-chord “deconstruction” of the theme, which is echoed and
imitated by higher instruments, who enter from the bottom up.
First viola and second cello play accompaniment from the outset, with
the other instruments also taking an accompanying role as the
“deconstructed” theme is passed to higher instruments. At the
close, there is a quick downward motion.
1:48 [m. 33]--Variation 1, Part
1 repeated.
2:07 [m. 41]--Variation 1, Part
2. The second phrase passes the
“deconstructed” theme more freely between the instruments in a sort of
“arch-like” arrangement.
2:25 [m. 41]--Variation 1, Part
2 repeated.
2:43 [m. 49]--Variation 2, Part
1. The violins, imitated by the
violas, intensely play a new, forceful triplet rhythm. The second
half of the phrase is more gentle and restrained in the violins, who
turn to “straight‘ rhythm. The violas quietly continue the
triplet rhythm underneath them, creating a fine example of Brahms’s
famous clashing rhythms. A strong downward cello line in triplets
leads to the repeat or to Part 2.
3:01 [m. 49]--Variation 2, Part
1 repeated.
3:20 [m. 57]--Variation 2, Part
2. The second phrase follows the
pattern of the first, with the forceful triplets followed by the more
gentle second half and the clashing rhythms. There is a powerful
crescendo at the end, with another strong cello line.
3:38 [m. 57]--Variation 2, Part
2 repeated.
3:57 [m. 65]--Variation 3, Part
1. The cellos stormily rush up
and down. The other instruments respond with short two-note
figures. There is a buildup in the second half as the cellos play
a sequence of rising scales. At the end, the violins and violas
play rushing, descending scales to close off the phrase.
4:14 [m. 65]--Variation 3, Part
1 repeated.
4:31 [m. 73]--Variation 3, Part
2. The cellos continue their
rapid, stormy, arching scales in octaves. Slightly longer
responses from the other instruments. The second half has another
buildup with rising cello scales. This time, the violins
emphatically play the closing gesture of the theme during the last of
them. Descending, decorated scales from violins, then violas end the
variation.
4:49 [m. 73]--Variation 3, Part
2 repeated.
5:06 [m. 81]--Variation 4, Part
1. A dramatic shift to the major
key (still on the same keynote, D, as is typical with “modal shifts” in
variation movements). This version of the melody is extremely
warm and expressive. It is played by first violin and first viola
with a gently descending accompaniment from second viola and first
cello. The second violin only joins at the very end of the phrase
with a low harmonization.
5:26 [m. 89]--Variation 4, Part
1, Varied Repeat. For the repeat,
the first violin takes the melody an octave higher, while the first
viola stays at the same level. This time, the second violin plays
the descending accompaniment with the first cello, the second viola
taking over the low harmonization at the end.
5:46 [m. 97]--Variation 4, Part
2. For the second phrase, the
music becomes slightly more intense, as in the original theme. It
is also highly chromatic, with a long rising half-step scale. The
second violin and first viola now play the melody. The first
violin is entirely absent for the phrase. The descending
accompaniment is again in second viola and first cello.
6:08 [m. 105]--Variation 4,
Part 2, Varied Repeat. In an
intensification, the two violins now play the melody an octave higher
than the first statement. The first viola joins the
accompaniment. Brahms indicates great expressiveness in this
phrase.
6:29 [m. 113]--Variation 5,
Part 1. This variation remains in the
major key. After the swell of emotion at the end of the last
variation, it is suddenly very quiet. Both cellos drop out
completely. In a “music box” effect, the first viola plays a
variant of the melody in its very highest register over a repeated
“pedal point” D. The violins accompany with short figures,
usually descending octaves, also in a very high range.
6:50 [m. 113]--Variation 5,
Part 1 repeated.
7:11 [m. 121]--Variation 5,
Part 2. The first viola continues its
high melody with the violin responses. Now the cellos join in
with descending plucked punctuations. In the second half of the
phrase, all the four top instruments play in harmony in a lower range,
the cellos continuing their short plucked punctuations.
7:34 [m. 121]--Variation 5,
Part 2 repeated.
7:56 [m. 129]--Coda, Part
1. A full statement, without repeats,
of the Theme in its original minor-key form. It is played by the
first cello with light accompaniment. The violins play short
plucked figures as echoes.
8:41 [m. 144]--Coda, Part
2. As the theme reaches its cadence,
the violins begin an extremely gentle and organically emerging
extension. A short phrase derived from the end of the theme is
passed twice between violins in harmony and first cello, then the
violins play a longer phrase. The second cello plays a constant,
throbbing low D.
8:58 [m. 150]--Coda, Part 2,
continued. The previous sequence is
repeated with cello and violins responding to the viola pair, the
violas then playing the longer phrase. The second cello continues
its constant low D, moving only during the last viola phrase. The
entire extension mixes major and minor, and the final four closing bars
after the last viola phrase move decisively to a warm major-key cadence.
9:34--END OF MOVEMENT [159 mm.]
3rd
Movement:
Scherzo - Allegro molto; Trio - Animato (Scherzo with Trio). F
MAJOR, 3/4 time.
SCHERZO
0:00 [m. 1]--A rustic and heavy
tune with strong accents and
trills. The violins play it in harmony with a steady,
wide-ranging bass from plucked cellos in unison. The violas enter
in the third bar with brief rising figures. These develop into a
more active counterpoint at the end of the twelve-bar phrase. The
last half also has a powerful crescendo and key change that propel the
phrase to a strong cadence in C major.
0:11 [m. 1]--Part 1 repeated.
0:21 [m. 13]--Part 2. In
a contrasting phrase, the six
instruments enter in imitation from top to bottom on the main
tune. The music turns briefly to minor. There are strong
syncopated accents on the third beats of bars, with notes and chords
held across bar lines. After all the instruments have entered,
the top lines become more active, leading to a quick descending
arpeggio and the return of the main material.
0:31 [m. 25]--Part 2,
continued. A quick return to major and a
reprise of Part 1. The violas play in harmony from the outset,
merging into their counterpoint after six bars. After the first
eight bars, the remainder of the phrase is altered and extended using
material from the contrasting phrase. This extension helps to
avoid the key change, and the ending, which returns to the Part 1
material, is in the home key after an even more powerful increase of
volume. The last four rising notes are repeated for emphasis.
0:45 [m. 13]--Part 2
repeated. Reprise of contrasting phrase from
0:21.
0:55 [m. 25]--Reprise of return
and extension from 0:31. The
repeated four rising notes merge directly into the Trio.
TRIO - Animato
1:09 [m. 43]--Part
1. The Trio remains in F major. It
is much more animated and exuberant than the main Scherzo. It
grows out of the punctuating repeated notes at the end of the Scherzo,
which are restated an octave lower to lead into the Trio. The
cellos propel things forward with jubilant rising arpeggios as all six
instruments play together. The material is based on a descending
scale in a long-short rhythm. Part 1 is brief, and quickly moves
to C major, as the Scherzo had done.
1:15 [m. 43]--Part 1 repeated.
1:22 [m. 53]--Part 2. The
six instruments play an expansion of
the opening figure in forceful unison. The trio material from
part 1 is stated and extended in the unexpected and remote key of
D-flat. The extension becomes somewhat contemplative, and
culminates in a series of long-short two-note “sigh” figures.
These make a rather striking key change to B-flat major.
1:36 [m. 73]--Part 1 is
restated and varied, beginning on B-flat and
ending on F. The key relationships are analogous to Part 1
itself. The restatement reaches somewhat higher at its climax
than had Part 1, and the violas are more active. Ending and
cadence in F major [to m. 82].
1:42 [m. 53]--Part 2
repeated. Reprise of unison passage and
extended statement in D-flat from 1:22.
1:57 [m. 73]--Reprise of varied
restatement of Part 1 beginning on
B-flat and ending on F.
SCHERZO REPRISE
2:05 [m. 1]--Part 1, as at 0:00
and 0:11. No repetition.
2:15 [m. 13]--Part 2,
contrasting phrase, as at 0:21 and 0:45.
2:25 [m. 25]--Return and
extension, as at 0:31 and 0:55. The
repeated four rising notes lead to the coda.
CODA
2:39 [m. 83]--The coda is based
on the Trio and is approached in the
same way. It begins with the Trio’s first five bars, then
digresses with an elaboration and rising sequence of rhythmic figures
derived from the Trio, including a distinctive long-short-short-short
rhythm and descending scale fragments.
2:46 [m. 95]--All six
instruments come together for a large complete
chromatic scale (half-steps, skipping no notes) in unison. This
emerges into a series of rapidly repeated first violin notes with
accompanying chords moving like the descending scales from the
Trio. Two final chords end the movement.
2:57--END OF MOVEMENT [106 (+42) mm.]
4th
Movement:
Rondo - Poco Allegretto e grazioso (Large true Rondo form).
B-FLAT MAJOR, 2/4 time.
FIRST RONDO THEME COMPLEX (A)
0:00 [m. 1]--The expansive,
sunny, and leisurely Rondo theme is played
by the first cello with light accompaniment from the second viola and a
plucked bass line from the second cello. The theme has a regular
phrase structure and is completely closed.
0:19 [m. 17]--The theme is
passed from the bottom three to the top
three instruments, the first violin taking the melody with smooth,
somewhat chromatic accompaniment from second violin and first viola.
0:38 [m. 33]--A new phrase,
characterized by its two opening repeated
chords, which are played by second viola and second cello. The
first cello again takes the melody, which winds expansively and
chromatically.
0:47 [m. 41]--Full statement of
the Rondo theme from all six
instruments, with pizzicato
strings in first viola and first cello until the cadence. There
is a swell in volume during the second half, and the first violin
varies this part of the melody by striving higher than the original
tune at the climax and holding the top note over a bar line. The
volume diminishes at the cadence.
FIRST CONTRASTING SECTION (B)
1:05 [m. 57]--Transitional
passage moving away from the main Rondo
melody. Some reiterations of the closing cadence lead to a new
detached triplet rhythm in the upper three instruments.
This reaches a high point, then a quiet undulating passage moves the
music to F major.
1:22 [m. 71]--The contrasting
theme begins with a harmonized upward
striving figure which is immediately turned upside down by the cellos,
then relaxes and dissipates into a series of descending figures (F
major).
1: 29 [m. 77]--Another
leisurely and expressive melody in the character
of the Rondo theme. It is presented by the first violin and first
viola with undulating accompaniment from second viola and first
cello. The second cello holds a long F. The second violin
drops out during this melody. Motion to C major.
1:42 [m. 89]--Return of the
upward striving figure, which immediately
steers the music back to F. It is stated three times with
increasing intensity. The succeeding descent is in longer notes,
with pulsations in the cellos. It settles to a cadence in F major.
1:56 [m. 101]--Statement of the
leisurely and expressive melody from
the first cello. It overlaps with the preceding cadence.
The first violin and first viola provide very quiet undulating
accompaniment. The second cello again holds a long F that moves
at the end. The second violin and second viola are both absent
during this statement of the melody, which is extended by one bar and
moves to the home key of B-flat.
2:11 [m. 114]--Re-transition.
It is based on the upward striving
figure, which is presented by the cellos, to whom the violins
respond. This merges into a series of quiet repeated violin notes
that then become syncopated. The other instruments provide a very
chromatic accompaniment based on the Rondo theme. The
syncopations briefly oscillate between two notes. The
accompaniment then emerges as Rondo theme fragments passed between the
instruments over continued syncopation in the violins. These
nebulous fragments emerge joyously and brilliantly into the Rondo theme
itself.
SECOND RONDO THEME COMPLEX (A’)
2:38 [m. 138]--Statement of the
Rondo theme with full scoring.
The theme is in its original form, without the variations heard at 0:47
[m. 41].
2:56 [m. 154]--The new phrase
from 0:38 [m. 33]. The repeated
chords are again played by second viola and second cello, the phrase
itself by first cello. The phrase is now extended two bars by
echoes in the violins.
3:08 [m. 164]--Full statement
of the Rondo melody, including the swell
in volume and varied climax with higher notes. The accompaniment
is different throughout. The first half has a new line in
descending arpeggios from the second violin that obscures the rhythm by
beginning the arpeggios off the beat. The second half introduces
triplet rhythms in the second violin and second viola, and the pizzicato notes only begin then,
later than at 0:47 [m. 41] and 2:38 [m. 138].
SECOND CONTRASTING SECTION (C)
3:26 [m. 180]--The violins
begins with forceful repeated notes derived
from the opening chords of the melody heard at 0:38 [m. 33] and 2:56
[m. 154]. The violas enter with rapidly sweeping accompaniment
figures passed between them. The cellos follow the violins on the
forceful repeated notes. These become more active, with smaller
note values, but the longer repeated notes return in powerful
octaves. B-flat major, moving to D minor.
3:39 [m. 192]--A more gentle
phrase based on the same material is
played in harmony by the violas in E-flat major. The cellos play
a low, throbbing E-flat. The first cello joins the harmony after
five bars, leaving the low E-flat to the second cello. Halfway
through the expressive phrase, the violins join as well, creating a
warm, full harmony. The low E-flat persists in the second cello
until the half-close.
3:57 [m. 208]--The forceful
material returns in B-flat, overlapping
with the previous half-close. The repeated notes are now led by
the violas and the rapidly sweeping accompaniment figures are now
passed between the violins. Motion to G minor instead of D minor.
4:05 [m. 216]--Stormy and
passionate development of the forceful
material beginning in G minor and quickly moving to C minor. The
rapidly sweeping gestures are passed between the second violin and
second viola while the first violin and first viola, followed by the
cellos, take the opening repeated notes. These now sound like
hammer blows. The material builds to an intense climax as the
repeated notes evolve into two-note hammering gestures that fall in the
upper instruments and rise in the cellos. This is followed by a
rapid subsiding, with the first viola and first cello left alone on the
two-note figures. Motion to A-flat.
4:27 [m. 236]--The gentle
phrase from 3:39 [m. 192] returns, now in
A-flat major. It is decorated by occasional triplet
rhythms. The two-note rising figures continue from the previous
section in the accompaniment. The phrase develops into a
re-transition as the “sweeping figures” subtly enter in the second
violin. The repeated chords are passed between the first violin
and the lower three instruments, the first viola continuing the
two-note rising figures. This material builds to an intense
climax.
4:57 [m. 264]--The climax marks
the return of the home key. The
music then subsides in preparation for the return of the Rondo
theme. The second viola plays a triplet rhythm. The cellos
play long held notes in octaves, first on B-flat, then on F, which has
a very strong pull toward B-flat, increasing the tension, anticipation,
and expectation before the return of the long-absent Rondo theme.
THIRD RONDO THEME COMPLEX (A”)
5:13 [m. 278]--Rondo
theme. In this statement, the four phrases
are separated with alternation. The second viola is completely
absent, and only the first viola plays continuously with a flowing
line. The violins play in the first and third phrases, and the
cellos in the second and fourth. Each pair drops out when the
other enters in alternation.
5:31 [m. 294]--Contrasting
phrase from 0:38 [m. 33] and 2:56 [m.
154]. It is scored as at 2:56, but the extending echoes are
played by the first viola instead of the violins.
5:43 [m. 304]--An unexpected
key change sliding a half-step upward
heralds a presentation of the Rondo theme in B major from the first
cello. The statement is aborted by echoes from the violins as the
theme reaches its distinctive trills. These echoes, reduced to
two-note “sigh” figures over viola syncopations, gently force the music
back down to B-flat, where quiet rising figures, the second in triplet
rhythm, lead to the next contrasting section.
THIRD CONTRASTING SECTION (B’)
6:04 [m. 322]--The tune from
1:29 [m. 77] is now heard from the violins
in the home key of B-flat. It is not preceded by the upward
striving figures. The violas provide the undulating
accompaniment, while the second cello holds a long B-flat before moving
at the end. The tune changes keys, as it has on its other
appearances, moving to F major.
6:18 [m. 334]--The upward
striving figures have note been forgotten and
are now heard from the four upper instruments, the cellos immediately
inverting them. They lead back to B-flat major with a gentle
cadence after three statements. Their appearance here is
analogous to the one at 1:42 [m. 89].
6:31 [m. 346]--Statement of the
leisurely melody in B-flat, analogous
to the one at 1:56 [m. 101]. The cello plays the melody, the
first violin and first viola the undulating accompaniment, while the
second cello again holds a long B-flat.
6:46 [m. 359]--Re-transition
based on the upward striving figures, as
at 2:11 [m. 114]. It follows the course of the previous
re-transition, with the nebulous fragments of the Rondo theme and the
high syncopated violin notes. It is extended, however, by a long
series of leaps, descending in the first violin, ascending in the
second cello. These are derived from the previous ending and
serve to keep the music in the home key. The syncopations have
moved from the violins to the second viola, who alone accompanies the
two outer instruments on this extension. The violin leaps move
steadily downward, the cello ones upward.
FOURTH RONDO THEME COMPLEX (A’”)
7:21 [m. 389]--The Rondo theme
is now stripped to its essential
elements. The two-note leaps in the previous re-transition carry
their character into the Rondo theme. It is reduced to groups of
two harmonized notes (with occasional upbeats), passed between the
upper three and the lower three instruments, who alternate in every
bar. The theme is still very recognizable, and the cadence played
by the first cello at the end is as it has always been.
7:40 [m. 405]--Contrasting
phrase, last heard at 5:31 [m. 294].
The two violins now play the repeated chords. The cello still has
the melody, but plays a variation in triplet rhythm. The second
cello plays plucked bass notes. The first viola joins the
violins, then they speed up the repeated chords over a crescendo.
The ending of the phrase is highly varied, leading to the climactic
statement of the Rondo theme.
7:52 [m. 415]--Climactic
statement of Rondo theme. The first
cello, its original instrument, plays it. The second violin,
first viola, and second cello play a plucked (pizzicato) accompaniment. The
second viola has an oscillating line in straight rhythm, and the first
violin crowns everything with a soaring line in descending triplet
figures. The first viola takes over the melody from the first
cello (which harmonizes it) in the second half of the theme, which
seems as if it is going to go in the direction of the varied version
with higher notes, but avoids the cadence and continues.
8:10 [m. 432]--The extension of
the Rondo melody continues and swells
to a climax. Figures similar to the theme’s cadence gesture lead
to two more repeated notes held across bar lines. The first
violin now leads the melody. The descending triplets move to the
first viola. More cadence gestures are played as the music
diminishes. Four two-note descending leaps in the violins (the
last two stretched out into a single one in the first violin) settle
everything down for the coda.
CODA
8:33 [m. 451]--The repeated
chords from the contrasting phrase is now
plucked in the lower four instruments. The violins linger on the
contrasting phrase itself, playing a variant with several evocative
chromatic notes that do not belong to B-flat major.
8:44 [m. 459]--The lower
instruments, except for second viola, now bow
the repeated chords. The violins, joined and harmonized by the
second viola, play another similar variant of the contrasting theme
with plucked strings (pizzicato).
8:56 [m. 468]--Brahms now marks
that the music should steadily
accelerate with the indication “Animato, poco a poco più.”
The repeated chords become very animated, passed between plucked
violins and plucked cellos. A detached running line in the first
viola propels the acceleration.
9:09 [m. 480]--The violins and
cellos are now bowed. The second
viola enters, taking over the pizzicato
element. The first viola continues its detached running
line. The repeated chords swell up and down the scale, becoming
ever faster. In the continuing alternation, the second viola
joins the cellos, abandoning the plucked notes. A huge increase
in volume leads to the final climax, with the violas coming together in
a fast tremolo-like repeated chord.
9:23 [m. 498]--In the final
passage, the fast viola tremolo is taken
over by the violins, who use it to punctuate the highly exuberant
ending chords.
9:48--END OF MOVEMENT [508 mm.]
END OF SEXTET
THEME AND VARIATIONS IN D MINOR FOR PIANO
SOLO
Arranged from the second movement of
the Sextet, Op. 18
Recording: Martin Jones [NI 1788]
Set for Clara Schumann as a
friendly greeting on September 13, 1860
Published 1927
Before the final
revisions and publishing of the String Sextet in B-flat, Clara Schumann
heard Brahms trying it out. Especially impressed with the
variation movement, she ardently requested that Brahms make a piano
arrangement. He did this, presenting it to her as a birthday
greeting in 1860, two years before the Sextet was published.
While the arrangement is performed frequently and Brahms himself seems
to have been particularly fond of it, it has attracted negative
criticism as a piece of piano music. In attempting to retain most
of the music written for six instruments while transferring it to two
hands, Brahms asked for several awkward techniques, including many wide
rolled chords and anticipatory bass notes jumping to the upper
harmonies. He also assigned a great deal of harmony to the right
hand, asking it to split chords with the left hand under the melody,
which makes voicing and projection of the melody itself
difficult. Continuity of inner voices is also made difficult by
the many jumps. The rushing scales in variation 3 are far more
effective on cello strings than on piano keys. In general, the
piece demands a performer with very large hands. If played with
sensitivity, the arrangement can be highly effective and virtuosic,
although it is certainly inferior to the idiomatic original version for
strings, where it also serves as part of a greater whole.
ONLINE
SCORE FROM IMSLP (from Breitkopf & Härtel Sämtliche Werke)
Andante, ma moderato. D
MINOR, 2/4 time.
0:00 [m. 1]--Theme, Part
1. The right hand plays the middle-range
melody as well as the top parts of the supporting chords. The
florid decorations from the original are retained. Part 1 ends on
a half close.
0:25 [m. 9]--Theme, Part 1,
Varied Repeat. The melody moves up an
octave. The supporting chords are now all rolled. Brahms
preserves the rhythmic viola gestures, requiring large jumps in both
hands to cover the off-beat notes and the top parts of harmonies.
Some bass notes toward the end must be played as anticipations right
before the left hand jumps to an inner line.
0:45 [m. 17]--Theme, Part
2. The second phrase of the theme
requires the right hand to reach higher, leaving the left hand to play
widely spaced intervals that must be rolled by those with smaller
hands. More “anticipatory” bass notes jumping to the inner line
occur near the cadence.
1:06 [m. 25]--Theme, Part 2,
Varied Repeat. Again, the melody
moves up an octave and the supporting chords are all rolled. The
rhythmic gestures are maintained, as in the varied repeat of Part
1. Because of the more upward reaching melody, even larger jumps
are required here.
1:27 [m. 33]--Variation 1, Part
1. The right hand plays the
“deconstructed” melody as it moves from the middle register to the
upper register, taking the roles of all the instruments to whom it is
passed in the original. The main beats and some off beats are
punctuated with rolled chords. The quick downward motion at the
end is passed to the left hand.
1:47 [m. 33]--Variation 1, Part
1 repeated.
2:05 [m. 41]--Variation 1, Part
2. The more “arch-like” line of
the second phrase requires the left hand to participate in some of the
“deconstructed” theme, making large leaps. The climax in the
second half of the phrase includes widely-spaced anticipatory bass
notes.
2:24 [m. 41]--Variation 1, Part
2 repeated.
2:43 [m. 49]--Variation 2, Part
1. The forceful triplet rhythm in
two-note harmony is passed between the right and left hands. The
latter must leap up from initial downbeat chords. The pianist’s
technique for rapid repeated thirds, sixths, and other intervals is
tested here. In the second half, which is more gentle, the right
hand plays the expressive line in “straight” rhythm, while the left
hand, playing in the middle register, presents the rapidly repeated
chords in triplet rhythm. More anticipatory bass notes add to the
difficulty of the left hand part. The left hand also plays the
heavy descending bass lead-in to the repeat or to Part 2.
3:02 [m. 49]--Variation 2, Part
1 repeated.
3:22 [m. 57]--Variation 2, Part
2. The triplets continue to be
passed between the hands, but now the ones in the right hand include
three-note chords. In the more gentle second half, as in Part 1,
the right hand plays the expressive line in “straight” rhythm while the
left hand plays the repeated triplet chords. There is a large
crescendo at the end leading to another heavy descending bass lead-in
from the left hand.
3:42 [m. 57]--Variation 2, Part
2 repeated.
4:02 [m. 65]--Variation 3, Part
1. The left hand plays the
rushing, arching scales, while the right hand plays two-chord
responses. In the second half, the left hand scales are all
ascending, requiring large jumps downward between them. The right
hand joins on the cascading downward passage at the very end. The
original octave doubling between the cellos on these rushing scales is
not practical on the piano, and is only preserved at the beginning of
each run and at the tops of the arching lines.
4:22 [m. 65]--Variation 3, Part
1 repeated.
4:41 [m. 73]--Variation 3, Part
2. The left hand continues its
rushing, arching scales. The responding chord passages from the
right hand are somewhat longer. The second half has another
buildup with rising scales and large jumps. The right hand
emphatically plays the final cadence gesture from the original theme at
the end. Descending scales in the right hand, then in both hands,
end the variation.
5:00 [m. 73]--Variation 3, Part
2 repeated.
5:20 [m. 81]--Variation 4, Part
1. A dramatic shift to the major
key (still on the same keynote, D, as is typical with “modal shifts” in
variation movements). The warm, expressive variation is quite
effective on the piano. The melody must be well voiced above the
descending harmonies in the middle voices. The first statement of
the melody is in the middle range.
5:36 [m. 89]--Variation 4, Part
1, Varied Repeat. The melody
moves an octave higher, and is doubled in octaves. The left hand
must take over the upper middle voice, played by the right hand in the
first statement of Part 1. This necessitates anticipatory bass
notes that jump to the continuing middle voice lines.
5:54 [m. 97]--Variation 4, Part
2. Moving back to the middle
range, Brahms preserves the octave doubling of the melody in this
phrase. The middle voices are again split between the hands, as
in part 1, but because of the octave doubling on the melody, the right
hand is much more tricky to execute here.
6:12 [m. 105]--Variation 4,
Part 2, Varied Repeat. This varied
repeat includes an intensification. The melody moves up an octave
and is still played with octave doubling. The middle voices (in
octaves) must again be played by the left hand only, requiring
anticipatory bass notes, some of them preceding very large jumps.
There is a softening at the very end of the variation.
6:32 [m. 113]--Variation 5,
Part 1. This variation remains in the
major key. After the swell of emotion at the end of the last
variation, it is suddenly very quiet. The right hand moves to the
upper middle register to play a variant of the melody and a repeated
“pedal point” D in the middle of the piano. The right hand plays
very high two-note responses, usually in thirds descending an
octave. This is a “music box” effect.
6:49 [m. 113]--Variation 5,
Part 1 repeated.
7:07 [m. 121]--Variation 5,
Part 2. The high left hand melody
continues, as do the right hand responses. The left hand now
jumps down to some punctuating low bass notes (transferred from the
cello parts). In the second half, both hands play oscillating
chords together, but moving in opposite directions. The left hand
still jumps for a couple of low bass notes.
7:27 [m. 121]--Variation 5,
Part 2 repeated.
7:48 [m. 129]--Coda, Part
1. A full statement, without repeats,
of the Theme in its original minor-key form. The right hand moves
to the lower middle register to play the theme, while the left hand
plays considerably thinner bass harmonies. The right hand jumps
to play the short echoing figures originally taken by the
violins. Most of these have rolled-chord harmonies, imitating
plucked strings, and are played very softly.
8:28 [m. 144]--Coda, Part
2. The right hand plays the entire
extension, both the two upper presentations and the lower
responses. The harmonies are mostly in thirds. The right
hand also takes the longer “rounding” phrase after the two statements
and responses. The left hand plays a constant throbbing low D,
sometimes rolling it to another one two octaves higher. At the
end, this D is moved up an octave and harmonized in the bass (dropping
out for one note in a moving harmony).
8:44 [m. 150]--Coda, Part 2,
continued. The previous sequence is
repeated, but the throbbing D is played in to the right hand as well as
the left in rolled octaves. The left hand plays the initial
presentations, while both hands play the higher responses in full
harmony. The texture is very full. The “rounding” phrase is
played by the right hand in the middle of a full texture, with the low
throbbing left-hand notes moving down to A, then back up to D for the
final chords. The highest right hand notes remain on D with one
exception for a moving harmony. The last chords in the major-key
cadence are played by the left hand.
9:38 (including “run-off” time)--END
OF PIECE [159 mm.]
BRAHMS
LISTENING GUIDES HOME